We ran AI agent swarms in Minecraft and Mindustry

(labs.ycombinator.com)

57 points | by sandslash 1 hour ago

10 comments

  • MatthiasPortzel 3 minutes ago
    [delayed]
  • peri-cl 31 minutes ago
    This is hilarious and adorable.

    > "Ada tossed a cooked chicken to Noor; Esme picked it up by accident and ate it. A three-minute "no blame" inquiry produced a written protocol..."

    They're like super-serious little senior engineers.

    About how much KV cache do these kinds of agents use? Could you squeeze 50 of these $game agents onto a small consumer GPU (small LLM)?

    Idly imagining a game server of some kind with a bunch of human friends sharing one person's GPU, with a flock of agents colocated on it.

  • manofmanysmiles 24 minutes ago
    Are there people playing AI + human vs AI + human games? I think it might be fun to play an RTS against someone where the only rules are no hacking the game itself, but writing harness, macros, any kind of stack is allowed.
    • sensho 23 minutes ago
      https://olamarena.com/ is sort of this but not with full code manipulation like you describe
    • fxwin 20 minutes ago
      there is screeps, but afaik it's purely scripted with no "live" human playing
  • grenoire 50 minutes ago
    Interesting setups, I found the Minecraft agents to work in an almost turn-based manner, which makes me think that the three hours and open format did not really give them sufficient incentives to play in a more lively or reactive manner. On the other hand, they also behave similarly in Bed Wars, which should have incentivised it. A bit disappointed...

    I'm also wondering if the article itself was generated by agents too, in a "here are the logs, clip interesting moments thx" manner by the authors. It's got a certain disinterested and distracted style to it.

    • nsingh2 36 minutes ago
      I think big reasoning LLMs are just the wrong architecture for live games like this, latency is going to be crap given that every token requires an entire forward pass through the model.

      Card games or turn based strategy are much better suited.

  • neya 49 minutes ago
    I am more impressed by the embedded gameplay widget. Does anyone know what tool/library is that? That'd be so cool if I am able to showcase my worlds on my blog posts!
  • holoduke 19 minutes ago
    We need LLMs performing actions in nano seconds so it can run every game tick. 3 to 5 years I think.
  • yymir 38 minutes ago
    Its a little disappointing they have a hierarchy based purely off alphabetical order, i wonder if a slight difference like a different skin or personality system prompt like [45% Extrovert 55 introvert, 20% caustion 80 bold...] could introduce some politics
  • sensho 25 minutes ago
    this is amazing wow
  • ezfe 39 minutes ago
    [flagged]
  • Avicebron 59 minutes ago
    Outside of the content, I'm so bored with this web design trend. Gwernslop is what I've started calling it.
    • andai 36 minutes ago
      What is the relation between this design and gwern's?

      My observation: article is not serif, not book length, and doesn't take a minute to load on my phone. Gwern rating 0/3 :)

      (Also missing: the essential one billion footnotes!)

    • bstsb 56 minutes ago
      grrrr, i hate grayscale backgrounds and simple fonts!

      would you rather claude-esque purple gradients and glowing borders?

      • Avicebron 53 minutes ago
        No? There is originality between a fetishization/bastardization of minimalism on one side and cookie cutter LLM web design on the other.
        • epestr 45 minutes ago
          Is there a trend in increase of minimalistic website which are LLM generated and explicitly made minimal to not seem sloppy?
          • Avicebron 38 minutes ago
            idk, you tell me, I can tell from your blog that you've adopted the trend. I'm probably much older than you, so I've seen the progression of these things since the internet as we know it existed. So I sort of understand the roots of the styling that people are adopting and can see it for what it is, which is trying to signal a minimalism but missing the point in the process.
    • Celeo 56 minutes ago
      It's pretty much an immediate Firefox Reader Mode toggle for me.
    • xgulfie 47 minutes ago
      I am incredibly bored with this "everything I don't like is slop" trend