Splash-free urinals for global sustainability and accessibility

(academic.oup.com)

57 points | by u1hcw9nx 52 minutes ago

17 comments

  • danjc 41 minutes ago
    Worth noting that this study was partially funded by the university of Waterloo
    • pfdietz 36 minutes ago
      Nominative determinism.
    • asdfasvea 19 minutes ago
      Nice domain name too.
  • harvie 7 minutes ago
    Sometimes i am using an urinal and i feel like no engineers were involved in the design. Glad to see someone is actually approaching this with proper science.

    There is more to it than the splashback tho. Sometimes it seems that the surfaces that already have splashes on them are not angled properly to lead the water to the drain. This seems to create need to have sharp edge/lip rather than round one, which might be tricky to make resilient in porcelain. But the rounded lip certainly allows for droplet flow towards the user rather than the drain hole.

  • u1hcw9nx 52 minutes ago
    Design through physics and differential equations.

    This paper is Ig® Nobel Physics Prize Winner 2026 https://improbable.com/ig/winners/

  • danw1979 23 minutes ago
    The recent introduction, in the UK at least, of splash-back reducing urinal … mats (?) has basically solved the problem in my opinion. They’re a disposable (but not single use…) plastic freshening insert with loads of short rubber strands, closely packed.

    You can pee on one of these mats and the stream almost aerates itself on impact and you get basically no splashback, I guess with a similar mechanism to how an aerating tap produces a stream of water that doesn’t splash off whatever it hits.

    • RattlesnakeJake 21 minutes ago
      We've had those in the US for several years now, and they work really well.

      I did encounter an upside-down one yesterday. That was... counterproductive.

  • d-e-r-e-k 13 minutes ago
    Global sustainability and accessibility seems a bit grandiose lol. It’s just a urinal after all. That being said, it’s been 4 years since Waterloo first determined this and it’s still unavailable to purchase. I’ve been patiently waiting for one to install in my shop but it seems like it’s not all that important for the globe if it’s still unavailable 4 years later.
  • ahoka 26 minutes ago
    I really like the inverted version, where it's almost guaranteed to splash yourself as a deterrent.
  • masfuerte 29 minutes ago
    Traditional urinals [1] are very effective. As are the steel variants [2]. The latter tend to become very grim over time.

    [1]: https://www.hlwashrooms.co.uk/healey--lord-niagara-urinals--...

    [2]: https://acornthorn.co.uk/urinals-wcs-cubicles/urinals/ur068-...

  • falcor84 24 minutes ago
    > droplets which travel back onto the floor and user

    I suppose this disproves Tufte's "There are only two industries that call their customers 'users': illegal drugs and software."

  • nelox 30 minutes ago
    It’s not much help if the aim is off
    • consp 19 minutes ago
      Install the urin-no next to it to help "improve" the aim.
  • y-curious 18 minutes ago
    Direct link to the designs (c and d, with d being practical). Great paper honestly.

    https://academic.oup.com/view-large/figure/512223725/pgaf087...

  • fguerraz 9 minutes ago
    The previous design was piss-poor
  • plasma_beam 31 minutes ago
    The secret to splash free male urination is..sitting down.
    • bluebarbet 30 minutes ago
      In a public toilet? Not happening. Back to square one.
      • quickthrowman 17 minutes ago
        I fail to understand why anyone is scared to place their bare thighs on a public toilet seat. Do you have open wounds on your legs?
      • Ylpertnodi 13 minutes ago
        Always carry wipes?
    • scythe 3 minutes ago
      Even women won't consistently sit down on public toilets
  • ButlerianJihad 6 minutes ago
  • b3lvedere 24 minutes ago
    This reminded me of some scenes in the videogame Dispatch [1]

    [1] : https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/dispatch/images/c/ca/Dispa...

  • asdfasvea 19 minutes ago
    Sustainability?

    What resource will we run out of if we continue to piss in traditional urinals?

    Has bullshit marketing terms invaded scientific papers now as well?

    • bobsmooth 14 minutes ago
      Water and chemicals spent on cleaning. Less splash means less cleaning.
    • vlyan 7 minutes ago
      [dead]
  • shafyy 28 minutes ago
    Somebody tell Larry David about this
    • trwhite 25 minutes ago
      No defecation allowed
  • manarth 34 minutes ago
    TLDR: The "Cornucopia" has the least amount of splashback, however the "Nautilus" is the recommendation of choice, to accommodate ease of cleaning and variations in the height of the user.

    https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/4/4/pgaf087/80987...